thomasroche ([info]thomasroche) wrote,
@ 2006-01-10 16:49:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
I am a very bad man
I am a bad person and my own pathology is illuminated by the fact that I can't stop writing shit down about the JT Leroy song & dance. I apologize. I just can't stop. I should be locked away.

BUT.....

I just can't fail to quote & link Violet's amazing post about her early life and why this JT Leroy cultural spazattack is not about a pseudonym, or gender identity, or a clever hoax, or any of that shit.

I hate to give any more ink (ok...pixels) to a hoax that will assuredly only result in vast amounts of fame and bazillion-dollar movie deals for its perpetrators. But Violet of all people has earned the right to bitch about it, so here goes:

Reading LeRoy's book brought so much back for me that I didn't see why I should re-live it. I'm okay now; it took me years before I could even tell anyone about my life prior to the age of 20. But I do remember one thing very clearly right now. On the streets we had a word for people like so-called LeRoy. It was "poser."

Susie Bright up next, in a stirring moment from her blog post on JTL:

I’m embarrassed to tell you all the nutty things I did. Every time he was mean, or screwed up, I always told myself to stay steady and kind. Why did I make the effort? I’m no saint. But from listening to him, I believed the childhood he described surviving would have killed anyone else.

I know Susie, I adore Susie, and I respect her. She's been a big influence on me, and she's brave to fess up. Which is why I have something I need to say to everyone who's ever covered for anyone in the community who was a fuckwad whether because of drugs, liquor or just plain being an asshole (it is causing me physical pain not to mention names here, but I won't). This goes out to everyone, myself included, who has uttered meaningless platitudes about the elephant in the living room and what a nice shade of gray it is while said elephant lays a fat stinking turd in your lap.

When we as professionals make such judgements -- "That person's childhood would have killed anyone else," "This person can act badly, it's OK because his Dad slapped him around," "Oh, he couldn't help himself," "She didn't mean it," "That's just the way she is," we do a great disservice to the other people who ALSO survived, and didn't ask for any favors. We make a decision about whose childhood was REALLY bad -- and fuck everyone else. It is not even a hair's breadth from "This person was abused, so just smile and nod when they go ballistic" to "That person abused me, but it was my fault."

Want to know a secret? Of course you don't, but I'll tell you anyway. I've spent way too much of my life covering for drunks, drug fiends, liars, opportunists and losers, and I understand how humiliating it can be when you discover they used the living fuck out of you and put you away wet. When someone else gets used and I don't, I find that getting to say "I told you so" is about the least satisfying thing I have ever experienced. I am so hot and bothered about what Susie went through because I have done that shit myself, a million times it sometimes feels like, and it hurts me to remember.

So, for the record: Fuck off, JT or whoever you are or aren't. Just fuck the fuck off.



(Post a new comment)


[info]pantryslut
2006-01-11 01:04 am UTC (link)
I especially appreciate the link to Violet's piece. Thanks.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]thomasroche
2006-01-11 01:10 am UTC (link)
[curtsey]

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]darklady_produc
2006-01-11 01:08 am UTC (link)
Ya know, I've made excuses for dicks in the past... usually because they were playing me and I thought we were So In Love, but I don't use a bad childhood or drug use or anything else like that as an excuse for being a dick. A bad childhood is an excuse for hurting -- but there's no real excuse for taking that hurt out on another. I had a pretty fucked up childhood, too, but I don't run around using that as an excuse to fuck people over.

The bad childhood is the explanation for problems, it's no excuse for bad behavior. At some point we have to take responsibility for our own actions.

Of course, it's talk like that that gets me into trouble so often. (shrug) So be it.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]thomasroche
2006-01-11 01:11 am UTC (link)
Word up.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]chrisomatic
2006-01-11 01:23 am UTC (link)
I think the whole thing is so vile. My mind is sort of reeling because I feel like a lot of people like to say "Things like that never happen" when someone talks about the kind of life "JT Leroy" "had". Now there's one more strike against people who have survived such things. I want to figure out a way to buy Violet and Susie Bright 15 minutes alone in a room with "JT".

(Reply to this)


[info]docbrite
2006-01-11 01:35 am UTC (link)
I don't particularly want to be put in the position of defending J.T. LeRoy, who was never a close friend (we exchanged a couple of cards and e-mails) or one of my major favorite writers, though I did enjoy his books. However, I don't see how anyone other than the people directly involved can make the blanket statement that "it's not about gender identity." Will all due respect to Violet and other people who've had far harder lives than I can even imagine, it is very easy to toss around the word "poser." I've had it tossed at me dozens of times for my own gender issues, which have been dismissed by people who don't know me as everything from a publicity stunt to the actions of an attention whore. In reality, they are none of these things, but because I've chosen not to physically transition, I'm not a "real" transsexual to some people. They're certainly entitled to that opinion, and I acknowledge that I do not face the problems encountered every day by someone who has undergone/is undergoing gender reassignment. However, I know what I am, and other people's opinions don't change that.

I don't like a lot of the things LeRoy did, but I can't shake a gut feeling that confused gender identity did, in fact, have a lot to do with this hoax.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]thomasroche
2006-01-11 02:09 am UTC (link)
I do believe that for a writer I think writing in a gender other than a birth-assigned gender is a right so sacrosanct as to be utterly beyond question. For me. Ditto on the right to live in whatever gender is chosen, without getting called a "poser" or whatever for the gender presentation that other people perceive.

Weird that I wrote that I thought it was an important right for a writer, first, whereas I actually think the central right is to live in whatever gender you want....important no matter what someone does. I think my putting the writer first does illuminate my somewhat embarrassing prejudices, though, so I'm going to leave it.

Anyway....I can't say it doesn't enter in to the way I perceive this hoax, but I don't think I'm bugged at all by JTL being supposedly genetically female with or without any perceived level of transition and presenting as a male writer in his bio. That, I'm so fine with I can taste it.

I guess I don't have the gut feeling you're talking about re: confused gender identity, but like I said, I can't say with certainty that it doesn't enter into how I perceive all of this.

But what eats at me, I guess, is the idea that by presenting one's self as someone who had a particularly hard childhood, one gets get attention and caretaking, and....at risk of being an apologist for JTL....that's what it takes nowadays.

I already know that is very true in real life; it just makes me sad to be reminded that it is true for writers as well.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]chrisomatic
2006-01-11 02:21 am UTC (link)
Yeah, I guess I feel like gender identity could definitely be an issue with the "JT Leroy" situation, but how does that excuse all the false claims of the kind of life this person supposedly had or did not have (in terms of poverty, abuse, prositution ata young age, being HIV+)? It feels so manipulative to me.

I guess I am also confused on who you are seeing as the person having a gender identity issue. Is it the two authors who wrote as "JT Leroy" or the sister who posed as him? I'm not asking this in a snarky way, just a clarifying way.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]docbrite
2006-01-11 06:48 pm UTC (link)
Yeah, I guess I feel like gender identity could definitely be an issue with the "JT Leroy" situation, but how does that excuse all the false claims of the kind of life this person supposedly had or did not have (in terms of poverty, abuse, prositution ata young age, being HIV+)? It feels so manipulative to me.

It doesn't, of course. There's no excuse for these things, especially the HIV claim.

I guess I am also confused on who you are seeing as the person having a gender identity issue. Is it the two authors who wrote as "JT Leroy" or the sister who posed as him? I'm not asking this in a snarky way, just a clarifying way.

My guess would be the person who did the writing. As I say, though, this is simply a gut feeling; I don't know the people and have no way of knowing whether this is true.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]amelia_g
2006-01-14 04:43 am UTC (link)
I didn't care for the writing of whoever JT Leroy was and I think I only read stuff where I had a piece in the same collection or whatever, but I sure have read a ton of commentary on the hoax.

Yours is absolutely the best though. You cut to the heart of the matter, which is that the way we (yours truly included) will make all sorts of excuses for people who require constant pardons and handouts from those around them. When there are generally other people in similar or much worse situations, who are just not jumping up and down about their problems or hiding behind them.

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…